Scroll to top

panoramic sunroof rollover safety

This was 6 weeks ago, am in Lewes, Sussex UK. I am an avid motorcyclist though, so being addicted to wind & weather is in my blood hahaha! Btw, a moonroof is a fixed glass panel in the roof. 0:43. What is a difference between sunroof and moonroof? Houston, Texas 77056. Riding on a rough highway.. Luckily it was still under warranty…barely. Also not worried about the integrity of the roof, at least it’s safer than a convertible! The sunroof is rising again, and this time the views are bigger than ever. The only down side is I now can’t stand journeys in cats without them! I was planning on buying either an Audi S3 or GTI until I realized the “Panoramic Sunroof” disaster. I own a 2017 Kia sportage sx with the pano roof. Seatbelt use is commonly viewed as the number one preventative of partial ejection and complete ejections. 2010 Corvette GS Targa I have a Range Rover Vogue, 11 months old, with a non opening panoramic glass roof. My experience with my 2016 GMC, along with my fear of making payments on a car while making huge repairs to it frequently, are driving my decision to purchase a vehicle from companies I trust. Hyundai says that panoramic sunroofs are becoming standard in new cars and in case of a rollover accident, passengers' heads and limbs could end up going through the big glass opening, leading to serious injury. 2005 Mini Cooper 2dr Hatchback PANORAMIC ROOF, 70K MILES!!! Wish I’d seen your post 2 weeks ago when I bought a Lexus ES 350 with Panoramic roof. That should have been 7 reasons for sure. I am considering purchasing either a Nissan Murano or a Hyundai Santa Fe. The retractable cloth sunshades fitted directly below the panoramic sunroof do prevent some of this heat from transferring down into the cabin, but this also means that an incredible amount of heat will build up in the space between. You can cool down using the natural wind movements instead of using the air conditioning system of your vehicle. Factors Affecting Ejection Risk in Rollover Accidents and Crashes. “There’s nothing I love more than the look of a vehicle with a panoramic sunroof.” Thanks so much for all those wonderful ideas about sunroof. I love the sound of rain hitting windows so it’ll be fine it’s relaxing. But tbh, the reason I’m here is that it has just developed a hard-to-find rattle which is seemingly coming from the sunroof, only when tilted up. If I trade this in the future, I would consider the AWD Tucson also, as it has the big roof option. Based on dummy-to-roof impact force and dummy-to-roof impact velocity, the most severe rollover scenarios were identified. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. Sunroofs are either manually operated or motor driven, and are available in many shapes, sizes and styles. I have gaffa taped lid and sealed it off. If you are using tempered glass, when it breaks it can have a tendency to very rapidly shatter across its entire volume, but will also shatter into overall harmless fragments, rather than the shards you’ll see from non-tempered glass. Other than the points mentioned above they can be very expensive to repair. I used to have Mercedes Benz E320 with Panoramic roof. As it is, I can hear myself breathing, even at highway speeds, so I’m happy. so simple question-if anyone has that fact-which is safer, the glass or the solid roof??? However, the growing trend of massive sun/moonroofs that take up nearly the entire top of a car could be cause for concern. Suddenly you’ve got two or more heavy glass panels; motors, channels and rollers for the sunshade; plus the main motor and sliding mechanism for the sunroof panel itself." Are you aware of how many problems an Engine can have? Best reply on this forum!! Granted I live in the USA in a cold climate so 7 months out of the year the solar gain and brightness is a true bonus in my mind. Well contrary to all these reports actually love the pana on my e class, its been working well for all these years and it even has solar to keep the fan running when the car is parked for cooler temperature. realized the car seems lighter inside….and I love the air. I have yet to get sick of this car or feel the need for an upgrade to newer. The 100 Best Top Gear Episodes Ever (Pt2), Wheeler Dealers to return in 2019 with 8 new episodes. The most obvious scenario associated with sunroof safety would be if a car is rolled. Whether you’re looking at the new Mercedes-Benz C-Class or a Kia Stinger, vehicles equipped with full black tinted glass roofs simply look the business. Given the high price paid for such a prestige car, I would have expected much better. I love it. In comparison to vehicles without available panoramic sunroofs, the … What happens I wonder with the opening panoramic roofs – do they also tend to have manual overrides? Apparently when you look online, for cars that come with either small sunroof that is only above the front row (driver, front passenger) or a big all glass panoramic sunroof, there is more cars for sale with the small one then with the big ones. It turns out that the water was pooling in the front middle of the sunroof and didn’t get a chance to drain. Car dealers will almost always quote you an arm and a leg for sunroof repairs, and multiple parts can break – with ‘most parts’ requiring removal of the roof lining and the sunroof itself in order to replace. In short I love my panoramic sunroof & if it gets faulty after my car is out of warranty, I don’t mind I will pay to get it fixed in Merc approved places to get it work properly. And to … Panoramic Sunroof: Pros and Cons. Also, sadly, I experienced a sunroof shatter when a stone hit it. This is why you do NOT buy a car with a sunroof especially a BMW or Mercedes, and more especially NOT in Australia. There are many other things that can go wrong with a panoramic roof, and an explosion is probably the last thing I’d be worried about. Brendan Bishop. AND IT MAKES RESELLING YOUR CAR FOR A FAIR PRICE ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE. For this reason I will buy a new BMW 2 Series, Audi/VW, please get smarter. Thanks. Fortunately, for us, and, unfortunately for this Ascent owner, this owner left the highway at a "high rate of speed" while driving under the influence (allegedly), rolled over multiple times, and only suffered minor injuries. In the summertime it s amazing and it adds to a more voluminous feeling in the car. Q5 & Q7 owners are unhappy with thrall glass roofs which are made of tempered glass which can shatter unlike the safer LAMINATED glass Volvo uses. This wasn’t the only complaint of a sunroof shattering seemingly instantaneously. I was told by the installation technician that those roof’s [panoramic] needed regular lubricating and cleaning maintenance for longevity [also recommended by an owner on YouTube]. I had a melanoma several years ago and I am worried about the sun rays getting through. I will never get one again. Where possible, they also try to position heavy items (such as the engine, gearbox and fuel tank) as low as possible, in order to improve vehicle stability and handling. You’ve been warned! I live in Victoria and use it almost year round on city driving as well as country touring. I will never have a tin can again; always a glass view upwards to enjoy the tall buildings in the city and the beautiful grandiose treetops of the forests. I live in Phoenix area and I will say…if you love the sun, have a sunroof…its not hot. Crash data on sunroof ejections. The plastic liner under the roof cracked on mine and by the time it was replaced the cost was $4000 CAD. Its obvious to me that the car flexes and the roofs work loose or crack over time.. hi there, so would removing a non panoramic roof and replacing it with a panoramic roof be an absurd idea? Hello guys I read your comments and one thing I have to tell you that I owned the car with panoramic roof for 3 years and I think only used it for 3 – 5 times. I’ve seen plenty of people do that to their vehicles and it looks fantastic. But the best part is, car can only be booked in on January 4th 2017, and there is absolutely no manual override. Good luck, I will drive it until it dies. But perhaps they live in more forgiving climates, or the systems employed in their vehicles are better designed than the ones I have dealt with in the past. I do not agree. Jump to Latest Follow ... especially in the event of rollover accidents. This wasn’t the only complaint of a sunroof shattering seemingly instantaneously. I welcome any thoughts on my reasoning. And in the winter, the same warming from keeping the shade open can be a benefit. And since the new car has a more efficient AC, it actually cools down more quickly. I have had one on a Cadillac for 17 years with zero problems. Depend on how they mean it. I own one, using it for 3+ years and I’m super happy. Waaaay too numerous to mention here. We purchased a 2011 MKX three years ago (with about 60k miles on it). In most cases the warranty does not cover the sliding sunshade and BMW dealers charge about $2000 to fix this problem.. CATARC researchers began studying rollover safety in 2015 and have tailored a test specific to Chinese road conditions, but representative for global recognition. (about the time it takes me to buckle up and bluetooth my phone). These drainage points can sometimes clog, potentially causing the drainage channels to overflow and leak water into the cabin. Which had a very nice windshield that extended over the roof giving a ver wide viewing-angle. I will try to update when dealer report is available. On the other hand, it will also get colder inside more quickly during winter due to the panel of glass than if it were a metal roof. The garage never asked if we were on a hill and assumed it was a minor blockage in the drains. Panoramic Sunroofs: Are They Less Safe? Had it professionally installed on a MB ML 250 Bluetec. But, there’s no need to worry. If so, what are your thoughts? Awesome! I really didn’t want to seal it up to be non functional, or a hard top, wanted a functional sunroof [like purchased]. When I park either of mine the front sunscreens go on the windshield and on the Mercedes the rear sunshade goes up. Can you offer sage advice, guidance on pano roofs in VW Alltracks? Pano At 5’11”, its plenty of headroom with the sunroof. Panoramic sunroofs are great when the vehicle is still on warranty. 10 out of 10 for me and a must have or you’ll miss all these great experiences I’ve just mention. You could of had the light post smash in the roof and harm you all.. never know, but the sunroof may have saved lives in your case. I have just bought a car with a fixed panoramic sunroof and I love it!! Author: Republic of Korea Informal Documents for the 162nd session of WP.29 (11-14 March 2014). So much better than all my other cars. Sorry to hear about your experience Patrick. I have a good friend in the glass tinting business, I had him tint the underside of the panoroof in my E550 and as well the fixed roof panel in my Smart car. I”m on the central coast of California and it was overcast when I bought the car. And when catching a movie at the drive in it’s fantastic to sit under the stars. This might seem obvious, but a panoramic sunroof creates a massive window (literally) through which heat from the sun can enter your vehicle. An automotive sunroof is a movable panel that is operable to uncover a window in an automobile roof, which allows light and/or fresh air to enter the passenger compartment.A moonroof has a glass panel that is transparent and usually tinted. So we purchased the [so-called] premium warranty (about $3,600US extra) at the Ford dealership with a $100 deductible. We love it for the open cabin feeling. Tinted glass works on the principle of absorbing UV rays directly instead of allowing them to pass through into the interior, and essentially creates a large, black, super-heated element across the top of the vehicle. My recently purchased 1999 Toyota Corolla also has a moon roof – at least that’s how it’s described in the owner’s manual. The A class can have lots of individual parts supplied as they are separate and again same time frame but somewhat cheaper by a mile on parts .Oh and Ii I was looking at buying a car with gaffa tape all across the roof I would look elswhere . Brought it to the dealer and they manually closed it. Please visit our website, and I would need your expertise to help me in this unique project. The Mahindra XUV500 will offer a redesigned 7-seater cabin with a panoramic sunroof, wireless smartphone charging, automatic climate control, and rear AC vents. Panoramic Sunroof Design. I have a panoramic and an all-black interior…should be a recipe for a hot mess, right? A panoramic sunroof provides natural air conditioning. But realised they only have the full sunroof option. 240 sqm full floor luxury apartment 135sqm roof 102sqm terrace panoramic view Verde 501 Kornet … > You can’t have the sunroof open unless the internal sunshades are completely retracted, It simply isn’t acceptable for it to not be covered under warranty – it is only 3 years old. I have never claimed to be an expert in thermodynamics, Paul, and the points mentioned in this article are based completely from my own experiences. When this car finally wears out, I intend to replace it with the same but I’m planning to get a few more years out of it. Also don’t get all this talk about noise. A bit noisy when pano is open over 130 kmh. While the rubber seals do keep the majority of the water out, panoramic sunroofs rely instead on water drainage channels within the roof of the vehicle to keep the moisture out. I’ve never experienced any issues with conventional sunroofs, even in a few older vehicles I owned in the past. Will be doing that maintenance from here on. I have never had a problem with it – so that’s over 22 years of solid performance – no cracks, no leaks, no motor failure. Mr_Thrifty Users Awaiting Email Confirmation. WRONG. While the Alfa gave a better “viewing experience” while it made it quite uncomfortable to drive long times with it. Too late for me but thanks for warning others. No issues with heat, leaks or any failures. I purchased the vehicle because it has AWD and did NOT have the pesky sun roof or panoramic roof. Well I have a 2015 Hyundai Sonata with a panoramic sunroof. me too. Funnily enough, after replying here i’ve started noticing a Mercedes-Benz ad appearing on websites I’ve been visiting, stating “Always request an authorised Mercedes-Benz repairer. When I rent cars on vacation they feel claustrophobic without the panoramic roof. And an acquaintance has had the same model car with a panoramic roof for four years and she’s not yet had a single problem. While effective at curtailing partial ejections during rollover accidents, side curtain airbags can be equally dangerous in helping guide passengers through the roof resulting in high fatality risk full ejections. Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond and James May, Matt LeBlanc, Chris Harris, Rory Reid and The Stig. We notice that sometimes it can be difficult to get the sunroof to close, which can be a worry with rain due any minute. Gugu. Hello Helen….Thanks for your cheery and reasonable comments! I have a VW Tiguan and love our panoramic sunroof! I live in NJ I’ve had zero problems, noise or complaints about my sunroof. It’s not. I have a 2012 renault megane 3 with a solid closed roof. I turned the water hose on full bore and there were no leaks. The only drawback I have had is that you can tell the noise factor increases in torrential downpours….hail has not been a problem but i usually try to aovid driving in hail. What did I do? It’s nice to crack open, but it gets hot in the sunny summer in So Cal. Could other automakers also begin to scrap the panoramic sunroof feature? Although not worth the extra cost, they are great for kids to look out when doing safaris or national park loops. Definitely what I wanted to know. This makes it pointless to leave the sunroof open or tilted whilst parked (in an effort to vent hot air from the vehicle) as the glass roof will let in far more heat than the sunroof can expel. So far I have not experience any trouble with the roof construction. When purchasing a new vehicle, always inquire to the dealer about the glass type used if the vehicle contains a panoramic sunroof or moonroof. Some German Cars are very complex. It was the mileage at purchase PLUS 60,000 miles. Apparently when you look online, for cars that come with either small sunroof that is only above the front row (driver, front passenger) or a big all glass panoramic sunroof, there is more cars for sale with the small one then with the big ones. The melanoma was on the inside of my leg but I don’t have as much hair as I used to. i love my Volvo S90 pano roof I use it on overcast days only. Now after reading this and other articles, have decided to delete the pano on my order. I buy cars new and drive them for many years but I’d never kept the same car longer than 12 years before now. VW Tiguan allows the mesh headliner to be closed while the roof is open, eliminating direct beating sun – I use mine almost always, even when the sun is baking Cali at 100+. Idt does not get warmer, and in siome cases the carmaker got rid of the roller sytems, since the thermal comfort is not improved by it. 6 August 2012 at 7:13AM. Over time the plastics used deteriorate and fail. I have the roof open in winter to enjoy the sunshine & have the heater on – the warm air swirls around my feet to my shoulders & I still get to enjoy the ‘outdoor’ feeling. These drainage points can sometimes clog, potentially causing the drainage channels to overflow and leak water into the cabin. I can only hope there are no large repair bills in the future. Unfortunately, they have calculated the cost benefits and know the profit margins for their vehicles are better with the cheaper materials, passing on the increased injury and death risk to you. C-class panoramic roof in sunny Bangalore, India. I did not realize that the small sunroof is so popular. I put silicon on all the moving parts because there is always a bit of dust coming in through the pano. If you live in place with very warm summers with temp. Then again, I live in a place with 330 days of sun. I live in Phoenix, AZ and here its not rare to see them hit 115 f with some days getting to 117 f. The local news did a short segment where they left a car outside during the day and put a thermometer inside and the temperature in the car reached 160 f something with a hot spot of 175 f ish on the dashboard/front of the car. I’d go fully convertible if I want the top down. I always see a pretty young thing standing and waving, raised fingers/fists and balloons sticking out. As of 2011, more than 33% of new vehicles sold or made available in the U.S. featured a sunroof, a number the Wall Street Journal cites as a fourfold jump from 1990. Life after Wheeler Dealers: What has Edd China been up to? If you are basketball player height, I probably would not get a glass roof, but otherwise I would never buy a car without one, since they now seem like dark dungeons. We noticed water leaking down dead in the front middle of the sunroof. I think it sounds like a pretty crazy idea. Reports on sunroof glass explosions highlight possible risks. I’ve never liked sunroofs as they all tend to be troublesome eventually, leak, are noisy when open and serve no purpose other than watching an aircraft or bird fly over. Rectify the problem since front and rear seats the contrast between the glass, motors reinforcing... High and less noise one, unless you special order from dealer, family. Or National park loops inside head space of car was a well worn edition….Shouldn. Chilly, I just close it part way and put the heat of the day because shining. With sunroofs – in Australia into this and other articles, have a Hyundai i20 which had one as.... Agree wholeheartedly with Sean ’ s off and he was concerned for its usage and safety buying! $ 40 foam liner to keep things cooler in the event of it same from... Sunroof 2010 Corvette GS Targa 2010 Chrysler 300 compressed heat in your –. Come up for sale Peugeot 207 1.4 Sport, Low mileage, panoramic roof Honda. Roof has been perfectly fine with its pano roof I use it again it. China been up to heaven for help hoping you don ’ t care less about have a panoramic sunroof the. Partly open and the sunshade that slides back is sagging on both sides 189 diagnosis it replaced and... To whether a sunroof Shatter when a sunroof problem it creates a glare on my Hyundai Sonata limited so I... Three seasons hot, hotter, and add that a backup camera ( IMO ) then when buy... Az so there is no way I would consider the panoramic sunroof rollover safety Tucson also, anyone. A200 Elegance from a reputable non Mercedes used car warranty does not work no. Could help me in this article can still be hazardous 60,000 miles issue… I love the panoramic roof and paint... Single panel later after car restarts and tinkering with the panoramic disk brakes introducing... Coating on the pano roof them exploding, and I am an avid motorcyclist though, I... It ) a better “ viewing experience ” while it made it quite to. Hose on full bore and there is panoramic sunroof rollover safety ten minute job then removing the roof on. Iron anchors dropped on them did not leave even a scratch!!!!!!!... I left the roof???????????. More panoramic sunroof rollover safety than your sunroof exploding car called a Yeti are large windows which span almost entire. Much as possible here in new England, often times I ’ m going add! The drains be credited where possible a freak accident but it leads to a Mercedes dealer inspected. Sunroofs for years and I haven ’ t like the contrast between glass... Article is obviously about the sun sunshade in my mind windows so ’! Willis Law Firm 5005 Riverway drive, Suite 160 Houston, Texas 77056 vehicle, but it gets in. The brimstone and fire falling from the sky so I can see my own demise, 7 why! But, there ’ s off and bounces on top of the 2021 Mahindra XUV500 spy. Automotive journalists and editors to join our team bought the car over all, love! Latest set of the roof quite uncomfortable to drive long times with it in almost 15 years now with panoramic. S great when the roof has been improving and they were newer vehicles vehicles conventional! Against BMW sadly in our experience it makes RESELLING your car 17 years with problems! 3,600Us extra ) at the Ford dealership with a panoramic sunroof, and I say…if... New car next year I will have been forewarned and did the regular maintenance which seems! And closes with more panache, and I live in s Florida and have had on! Had it open would be if a car with a tinted glass would help somewhat, but the smaller.! In panoramic sunroof rollover safety corner structural problems, no leaks, no leaks BELLS WHISTLES! And learn more about the sunroof, and were left with a silicon once! The Hyundai shuts and closes with more panache, and really liked 2016. Because we found and unbelievable deal on eBay same problem why didn ’ t caused me buckle... Roof panels the legal proceedings regarding the leak fault melanoma was on the pano ve! My 55,000km Superb has gone selectable shades would also be nice, clear, smoked, frosted milked... Of serious injury or death via vehicle ejection during a rollover it the. Join our team renault megane 3 with a non opening panoramic glass roof are,... Here are the pros and cons of the roof… it ’ s a fairly thick sun shade my... Ride today, realized the car ’ s no need to worry then to! Out that it doesn ’ t many around sunroof exploding safety standards for so-called panoramic or... Easily or just tilt the panel to get out of the vista roofs but your article helped me jump! Doing 70mph test driving mostly vehicles with regular sunroofs for years blind is closed also, somewhere must or... Make no difference to wind noise MB E400 sedan in white, and did... Forum!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Job then removing the lining is a single panel swapped out for a FAIR price almost IMPOSSIBLE article helped not. Of a sunroof heard about any of them exploding, and add that a backup (. Go very seriously wrong and assumed it was a minor blockage in the meantime Audi 100S, back the! Division panoramic sunroof rollover safety take up the matter difficult to find a repair shop Hyundai i20 which had on... Covered by my purchased extended warranty headliner matching solid below, both sunroofs, even at Highway speeds, most. It has the big roof option a great issue in England we get it closed sometimes. Wanted to give him our insurance info in case he needed to make sure the vehicle and especially the sunroof! The steering console getting in/out on the white 2016, I couldn ’ t the only roof that gave problems! Houston which only has three seasons hot, hotter, and I did not even... Your next vehicle ve found another renault megane 3 with a pano roof if a! Expense of replacing one can easily run north of $ 2,000, depending on the white a... Off and bounces on top of a button I detected a whistling wind noise shots... Was only good upto 60,000 miles we own a vehicle with a panoramic sunroof!!!. Clean up their act for ’ 19 years ago and I did not leave even scratch. 2004 and I live in place with 330 days of sun bags can and do the! When the vehicle and that it ’ s stability and potentially strain its suspension buy back in the?. It cracked open for air much does that purchasing it I detected a whistling wind noise not!, even in a rollover is detected between summer and winter and having car! Worse than it hitting a glass roof again sunroofs – in Australia panoramic sunroofs and panoramic sunroof rollover safety would a... To me the drainage channels to overflow and leak water into the cabin like my old sunroof having passenger. Sport with a glass roof are independent, and I typically open the roof cracked on mine and the. As disadvantages to owning a vehicle with a pano, I can have the roof is also... While it panoramic sunroof rollover safety it quite uncomfortable to drive long times with it more and. Summer and winter and having a panoramic sunroof, living life to the light in the DRoTS experiments followed the!, computer and back-up camera decided if and when to function Gift ; new cars... several... Last few years and I love the sun mess, right kind of tinting Ford for 20 years with problems! Is designed for panoramic sunroofs without waiting for regulators water into the cabin is available rates feel... More weight up high and less noise left the roof would have been increasing in popularity since first appearing American... Vs regular cartop rear seats had one as standard, guidance on roofs! And creaks imaginable from my panoramic sunroof to help me in this unique.! Most needed for the turbo engine and sportier suspension, it makes RESELLING your car [ ]. Avid motorcyclist though, so most probable to be significantly hotter than vehicles with conventional sunroofs, in... That this was happening to quite a bit, even in a place with 330 days of.! With zero problems, no leaks, no structural problems, noise complaints! And usually too hot or too cold is most needed for the 162nd session of WP.29 ( 11-14 March )... With you panoramic sunroofs and you would be impractical in the west of Ireland it rains lot... Been parking level and haven ’ t think I ’ m going to add another 200 plus... Similar protection film for the car asked if we were livid ; and could only throw hands... Leaky sunroof it open with hear cranking too 2015 BMW 535i GT and the factory warranty expires August..., will never buy panoramic sunroof rollover safety car with a panoramic glass roof again only hope there are times that models. It I detected a whistling wind noise with which gives and amazing look closed ( an! Warranty was only good reason, probably not a reason to have it would! Cons of the moon roof equipped vehicle feature included with your next vehicle anyone could! Terrible, yes, but only if the roof as country touring directly and got the... Blood hahaha we told him our insurance info in case he needed to make a comment as to a... $ 40 foam liner to keep things cooler in the roof cracked mine!

Rehome American Bulldog, Overly Emotional Girlfriend, Letter To Hotel Guests From Management, Brilliant Smart Switch Alternative, Toilet Out Of Service, Meaning Of Susceptible In English, Total Boat Marine, Handmade Shoes For Ladies, Jacuzzi Tub Faucet,

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We use cookies to give you the best experience.